
BY GEOFFREY COBB | gcobb91839@aol.com
The story of 5Pointz in Long Island City is one of the most dramatic chapters in the transformation of New York City — and in the long struggle over whether graffiti should be regarded as vandalism, cultural expression, or fine art. Over the course of two decades, graffiti artists from around the world transformed a group of aging industrial buildings into what became an internationally celebrated center of aerosol art. An estimated 1,500 artists contributed work to the site, turning 5Pointz into a pilgrimage destination for graffiti enthusiasts. It functioned as a constantly evolving outdoor museum, a place where established masters of the form painted alongside younger writers developing their craft.
Its success, however, also unfolded against the rapid redevelopment of Long Island City. As the neighborhood changed and property values rose, the industrial complex occupied increasingly valuable real estate. Eventually, the interests of the artists who had made 5Pointz famous collided with those of property owner Jerry Wolkoff, who planned to demolish the buildings and redevelop the site.
Part of what made 5Pointz remarkable was the range of artists represented on its walls. Many of the most important figures in New York graffiti painted there, including artists with deep connections to the Bronx and the subway-writing era. TATS CRU, the celebrated Bronx mural collective known for transforming traditional graffiti lettering and characters into elaborate large-scale aerosol murals, was among the established New York names represented at 5Pointz.
Stay High 149, one of the foundational figures in New York graffiti, also painted there decades after becoming famous for his distinctive “Smoker” character and flowing tag. Tracy 168, another major early Bronx writer, helped pioneer and popularize the elaborate lettering associated with wildstyle. Cope2, whose career also reached back to the subway era, became one of the most internationally recognizable New York writers to paint at the complex. Part One, another influential old-school writer, brought the sophisticated lettering traditions of early New York style writing to its walls.
The person most responsible for transforming 5Pointz into a coherent artistic institution, however, was Queens artist Jonathan Cohen, better known as Meres One. A prolific graffiti writer and muralist himself, Cohen became the site’s curator, deciding who could paint and where. Under his direction, the exterior walls became much more than an unrestricted graffiti space. They operated as a vast, continually changing exhibition whose quality and international reputation attracted artists and visitors from around the world.
Women also played an important role at 5Pointz. Lady Pink, born Sandra Fabara, one of the most influential women in the history of New York graffiti, contributed work to the site. Ecuador-born and Queens-raised artist Toofly painted there as well, later becoming known for work spanning murals, illustration, and design. International artists were also represented, including acclaimed Japanese graffiti artist Shiro. Their presence reflected the breadth of the community that developed around 5Pointz and the increasingly international reach of graffiti culture.
The buildings themselves long predated the art that made them famous. Constructed in the nineteenth century, the industrial complex had once housed manufacturing operations, including a water-meter factory. By the 1970s, however, its industrial heyday had passed. Developer Jerry Wolkoff acquired the property and leased space to businesses and, eventually, artists.
By the 1990s, artists attracted by relatively inexpensive studio space were working inside the complex, while aerosol artists increasingly covered its exterior walls with murals. The site became known as the Phun Phactory before being renamed 5Pointz in the early 2000s, when Cohen assumed responsibility for curating the outdoor artwork. The new name suggested the coming together of artists from New York City’s five boroughs. As the site’s fame spread, Cohen envisioned something even more ambitious: transforming the enormous complex into a permanent museum devoted to graffiti and aerosol art.
That vision ultimately conflicted with Wolkoff’s plans for the property. As Long Island City experienced extensive development, Wolkoff sought approval to demolish the aging warehouses and replace them with residential towers. The artists, meanwhile, fought to preserve a place that had evolved from an industrial property into an internationally recognized cultural landmark.
Their most important legal weapon was the federal Visual Artists Rights Act of 1990, commonly known as VARA. The law gives creators of certain works of visual art rights concerning the attribution, modification, and destruction of their work. Particularly important to the 5Pointz case was its protection for works that had achieved what the statute calls “recognized stature.”
In August 2013, the New York City Planning Commission approved Wolkoff’s redevelopment plans. Efforts to secure landmark protection for the complex had also failed. Artists and supporters responded with protests and a campaign to preserve the site. Even Banksy, the famously anonymous British street artist, publicly supported saving 5Pointz during his month-long New York residency in 2013.
The decisive moment came in November. The artists had gone to federal court seeking to prevent the destruction of their work under VARA, but they were unsuccessful in obtaining preliminary injunctive relief. Then, during the night of November 18–19, 2013, Wolkoff ordered the murals covered with white paint. The sudden whitewashing shocked artists and supporters who had spent years building 5Pointz into an internationally known center of aerosol art. The buildings themselves were subsequently demolished as redevelopment moved forward.
Destroying the murals, however, did not end the dispute. Instead, the conflict moved from the walls of Long Island City into federal court. Twenty-one artists pursued claims under VARA, arguing that Wolkoff had unlawfully destroyed works protected by the statute.
The resulting case became one of the most significant legal battles involving graffiti and artists’ rights in the United States. In evaluating the artworks, the federal court considered such factors as expert testimony, the reputations of the artists, Cohen’s curatorial process, the artistic quality of individual works, media attention, and 5Pointz’s international prominence as a destination for aerosol art. The district court ultimately concluded that 45 of the works involved in the case had achieved “recognized stature” and therefore qualified for protection under VARA.
In 2018, U.S. District Judge Frederic Block awarded the 21 artists the maximum statutory damages available for the 45 works, a total of $6.75 million. The ruling was particularly significant because the works had been created with the property owner’s permission but were physically attached to buildings that the artists themselves did not own. Wolkoff appealed, but the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit upheld the judgment, including the conclusion that temporary works of art could qualify for VARA protection and that the works at issue had achieved recognized stature.
The destruction of 5Pointz represented an enormous loss to New York’s graffiti community. A place that had allowed generations of artists to paint, experiment, collaborate, and exhibit their work disappeared just as the surrounding neighborhood was being transformed by development. Its fate therefore became inseparable from larger debates about gentrification, property rights, cultural preservation, and who determines what forms of urban art deserve to survive.
Yet the destruction of 5Pointz also produced an important and somewhat paradoxical legacy. Wolkoff succeeded in demolishing the buildings, but the artists succeeded in establishing that the law could recognize aerosol murals as works deserving the same kinds of legal protections available to other visual art. The $6.75 million judgment could not restore the paintings that had been erased, but it demonstrated that an owner’s control of a building does not necessarily eliminate the rights of artists whose protected work appears on its walls.
In that sense, 5Pointz survived its own destruction. The physical complex disappeared, but the legal battle over its walls strengthened the position of street and aerosol artists under federal law. What had begun as an informal experiment on the walls of an aging Queens factory ultimately helped establish an important principle: art does not cease to be art simply because its canvas is a warehouse wall.
Geoffrey Cobb is the author of “Greenpoint Brooklyn’s Forgotten Past.