
Meng, Moreno call to expel agency from NYC, while Ariola blames man who was shot.
BY JACK DELANEY | jdelaney@queensledger.com
On Thursday, October 8, multiple vehicles driven by ICE agents surrounded 28-year-old Oscar Belgal in the Marble Hill neighborhood of Manhattan, demanding that he exit his car. According to federal officials, Belgal instead accelerated and allegedly drove towards the agents.
In response, an unidentified ICE agent fired seven shots through the front windshield with a pistol, though Belgal’s five-year-old son was sitting in the backseat — a fact which agents later claimed they weren’t aware of — and grazed the father’s left ear and neck. The NYPD arrived shortly after, handcuffing Belgal before rushing him to a nearby hospital.
Belgal was discharged later that night and transferred to federal custody at the notorious Metropolitan Detention Center in Brooklyn, which has faced renewed scrutiny this year for “inhumane” conditions.
The jail drew national attention in 2019 when a power outage left inmates without heat in the dead of winter; in 2024, a judge said the facility was still “barbaric,” and a report released last month by the Incarcerated Remedy Project found that one inmate who fell and fractured his spine was not taken to a hospital for 43 days.
Belgal’s lawyers said a bullet remains lodged in his body and that he is in pain, according to the New York Times, and his son has reportedly not spoken since the shooting.
On Friday, a federal judge blocked the government from deporting Belgal, whom Department of Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin described as an undocumented immigrant from the Dominican Republic who had evaded an attempted arrest by ICE in September.
“Regardless of whether or not someone has a criminal history, it is not lawful, it is not okay, to shoot a father in the afternoon with his son in the backseat,” Harold Soli, a lawyer representing Belgal, told ABC. “That is not how we resolve legal disputes in this country. We resolve them in buildings like these, in courtrooms.”
In Queens, which saw a surge of ICE activity this summer as part of “Operation Rotten Apple,” many local politicians reacted to the Marble Hill shooting with similar outrage.
“I can’t stop thinking about that little boy,” said Rep Grace Meng, whose district stretches from Maspeth to Alley Pond Park. “Let me be perfectly clear: Get ICE off our streets, out of our hospitals, away from our children. Get ICE out of our city, for good.”
“We must abolish this rogue and violent agency,” added Council Member Shekar Krishnan, who represents the immigrant-rich neighborhoods of Jackson Heights, Woodside, and Elmhurst.
Diana Moreno, the state assembly member for Astoria and Long Island City, echoed Krishnan’s calls to abolish ICE, while also insisting that NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch “end police assistance for ICE operations” and disband the Strategic Response Group, a counter-terrorism unit that has been criticized for violently suppressing protests.
Other Queens lawmakers placed the blame squarely on Belgal. In an interview with Newsmax, Council Members Vickie Paladino and Joann Ariola argued that their colleagues were needlessly interfering with law enforcement.
“It’s about villifying the police officers, villifying the ICE agents, and uplifting the bad guy,” said Ariola, who agreed with Mullin’s claim that Belgal had endangered his own son by attempting to flee the scene.
“Zohran needs to take a back seat to the federal government,” emphasized Paladino. “How dare he demand that this guy go free?”
But Mayor Zohran Mamdani himself, who once held Moreno’s state assembly seat, backed his left-leaning allies’ push to abolish ICE, which he said was “looking to blame the person and the city at large, as opposed to reflect[ing] upon their own actions.”