Don’t waste rail line
Apr 09, 2014 | 2452 views | 2 2 comments | 103 103 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Dear Editor:

Whatever happened to doing fair studies of finding the best solution to a problem?

It appears that the city has already made up its mind that we will have Select Bus Service (SBS) along Woodhaven Blvd just because it has six lanes, although traffic will be made much worse. There is not enough capacity as is, hence the banning of left turns at many intersections.

SBS will only save bus riders a maximum of 10 or 15 minutes of what is for many now a two-plus hour trip. However, reactivation of the Rockaway Rail Line could cut trip times in half.

It can be reactivated through many forms, and converted to a bus rapid transit line if it turns out that the economics and ridership is not there for a rail line. We can have the benefits of SBS and more without any of the negatives that go along with putting SBS on Woodhaven and Cross Bay boulevards

The important thing is that all options are fairly studied and the right of wat remains for mass transit usage. But turning it into a park eliminates that option.

To those of you who think we can have both - SBS along Woodhaven and future reactivation of the Rockaway Line - you are fooling yourself. Once SBS is constructed along Woodhaven Boulevard, the city will declare a ten-minute travel time saving a huge success and the transportation problem for those in the Rockaways and southern Queens will be “solved.” Reactivation will be dead.

A vote for Woodhaven SBS is the same as a vote for Queensway. No one will mention that auto and car trips on Woodhaven will increase by 30 minutes in exchange for the 10 minutes saved by buses.

And with the limited destinations of the buses, few if any auto riders will be able to switch from car to bus. They would still require four or five transfers, which is why they are in their car in the first place.

We must make transportation convenient for all, not slightly more convenient for a few and harm many more. Reactivation of the rail line will foster development, create jobs, help the economy and raise property values, as well as improving transportation. Queensway will do none of that.

Let’s have a fair study comparing the advantages and disadvantages of each option as compared to each other, and not draw conclusions beforehand like we are doing now.


Allen Rosen

Comments-icon Post a Comment
Philip McManus
August 29, 2015
Are you tired of the gridlock and overcrowded buses, trains, roadways and unfair toll bridges from Queens to Queens?

The Queens Public Transit Committee is having a rally against Select BS, Zero Vision and QueensWay to Nowhere!

We support faster and safer transportation including the QueensRail, citywide expansion of ferry, bus, train and roadway services.

Stop City Hall from stealing our time, freedom, safety and prosperity.

Our "Transportation for Everyone Rally" is on Sunday, September 13 at the corner of Woodhaven Boulevard, Queens Boulevard and Hoffman Drive from 3:00 pm to 4:00 pm near the southbound Q 52 & Q 53 Bus Stop. We will have a 3:30 pm photo opportunity for the media.

Will you join us and tell your family and friends to fight for faster and safer transportation?

Please let us know asap if you have more volunteers joining us.

We need is to tell the world that Select BS, Zero Vision, QueensWay to Nowhere, exclusive bike lanes and bus lanes divide, separate and isolate People and Money and stop City Hall from discriminating and dividing commuters and the outer boroughs.

NYC is Five Boroughs and not just the lower half of Manhattan.

Give us back the QueensRail, stolen bus routes, ferry service, travel lanes, free bridges, left turns, our speed limits, local bus frequency, faster railways and reopen and maintain our roadways closed to bike, bus lanes and paint.

The outer boroughs demand EQUALITY and COMMON SENSE!


Philip McManus


Queens Public Transit Committee

Faster transportation will create more social, economic, recreational, and environmental opportunities.


Rockaway Beach Rail Line

Queens Public Transit

Rockaway Beach Branch


Rockaway Beach Line


Rockaway Branch Line blog

Rockaway Branch Line Mission Statement

Queens Public Transit

Please support the following petitions:


Queens Rockaway Beach Line



Q 52 Bus

Station Agents

Metro North Station in Queens
Philip McManus
May 09, 2015
Let's stop the lies and the nonsense.. Queens and the outer boroughs need railway expansion including the QueensRail, the old Rockaway Beach Line which is two to six blocks east and parallel to Woodhaven Boulevard took 43 minutes to travel from Manhattan to west, central and south Queens. You are wasting your time, money and freedom stuck in traffic because City Hall and NIMBY politicians don't care about you or your family. We need to unite Queens not separate and divide Queens with more traffic congestion. Join the Queens Public Transit Committee.

Philip McManus