Commuter van industry growing in Maspeth
by Holly Tsang
Apr 22, 2010 | 8347 views | 1 1 comments | 136 136 recommendations | email to a friend | print
Image 1 / 2
A commuter van on Calamus Avenue and 72nd Place.
C.O.M.E.T. (Citizens of Maspeth and Elmhurst Together) President Roe Daraio never paid any attention to the commuter vans that operate throughout Queens until several members of her civic group made complaints about double-parked vans on residential streets in Maspeth and passengers that littered while they waited to be picked up. Suddenly, she started noticing the vans everywhere.

She decided to look into the commuter van routes, but was unable to find that information, so she made a FOIL (Freedom Of Information Law) request from the city. She received a packet of maps clearly indicating the geographic zone in which each van authority is allowed to operate. Information for Transxpress and J&HE, the van authorities that Daraio has received the most complaints about, was not included.

However, Daraio maintains that the commuter van issue never went before Community Board 5, a detail confirmed by CB5 District Manager Gary Giordano, who has held the post for 20 years.

According to Giordano, TLC-regulated vehicles are required to come before the board with base station applications and renewals, but he said that the protocol for commuter vans is unclear as the board has never been presented with an application or renewal for commuter van authorities.

Daraio said, “The lack of enforcement by TLC in our area is basically giving the green light to commuter van companies to operate outside of their authorized zones.”

To prove her point, in true vigilante fashion, Daraio and a friend patrolled the neighborhood last May and August, compiling a list that included the van authority name, license plate number, and pick-up/drop-off locations. She noted that commuter vans are actually permitted in South Elmhurst, but oftentimes she has observed vans making pickups and drop-offs around the Super Stop & Shop on Grand Avenue and 74th Street in Maspeth.

The problem, said Allan Fromberg, a spokesperson for the Taxi Limousine Commission, is that Daraio’s list was compiled some time ago and that commuter van routes and zones are subject to change. He said the Department of Transportation sets the zones, but commuter van authorities set their own routes. They can even go off their routes so long as they only pick up and drop off within their zones.

“Within that zone, they have the flexibility and ability to create routes that are specifically demand-responsive to their group of customers. It’s sort of like a custom bus route, if you will,” said Fromberg, likening it more to a school bus than a city bus.

Daraio said she contacted TLC about a year ago regarding the commuter van issue and some TLC enforcement agents came out and issued summons to commuter vans that had violations. Since then, however, commuter van drivers have gone right back to doing the wrong thing.

“This is one industry that’s totally not being monitored,” said Daraio, “but if you park at a parking meter they [the city] slap your butt with a summons.”

Fromberg said that the TLC has run every license plate Daraio has brought to them and always inspects the complaints she makes. He addressed another one of Daraio’s concerns regarding lost tax revenue to the City when commuter vans stop to pick up riders who flag down the vehicle instead of calling in advance. Commuter van authorities, said Fromberg, are private companies; TLC only licenses and regulates them.

Daraio is still convinced that commuter vans are illegally operating in Maspeth, but despite all the other problems they bring with them, her main concern is traffic. With school buses, city buses, commercial trucks, and personal vehicles regularly making the rounds in Maspeth, the traffic situation remains a sticking point.

“I don’t need more traffic; I need more traffic like I need a wart on my nose,” said Daraio, adding that at least five bus lines run through Maspeth, more than enough public transportation for the neighborhood. She added, “If there’s going to be a service, the community should be able to say whether they want it or not.”

Comments-icon Post a Comment
miss maspeth
February 13, 2012
I take this commuter van to Chinatown because Maspeth has horrible public transportation. We are such a short distance from Manhattan, yet it takes forever to get there. I understand that the area does not have it's own train and the Winfield Spur line that was built will never be put to use, but how about we turn the Q59 into an express bus to downtown or have some of the Express busess passing through Maspeth stop at Grand Avenue. Having an Express bus on Grand Avenue would increase foot traffic to help the already ailing businesses. The commuter van is awesome because there is a need for it. The people that complain about it don't probably drive to work and don't have to experience the painful public transportation every day. Fix the real problem and maybe there wont be